Blog

Word of mouth got me every student I have. It was also losing me dozens.

Somebody recommends you at the school gates. Three days later the parent has forgotten your name and is typing “guitar lessons near me” into Google, where you are one of forty. Here is what that costs, and what fixed it.

· 7 min read

usemyAn illustrative story

IllustrativeRob is not a real person. This is an illustrative story about how word of mouth works for a teacher, and the names, places and numbers in it are made up.

I have taught guitar in Stockport for fourteen years. About thirty five students a week, mostly children between eight and sixteen, a handful of adults on a Thursday evening who all say the same thing about having wanted to learn since they were twelve. Half hour lessons from the back room at home, some acoustic, mostly electric, grades if anybody wants them and nobody made to do them.

In fourteen years I have never paid for an advert. Every single student I have ever taught came from somebody telling somebody else. Which sounds like a boast, and for a long time I told it like one. It is actually the story of a leak.

The conversation that gets you a student

It happens at a school gate, or in a kitchen at a birthday party, or in the queue at a chip shop. Somebody says their lad has started asking for a guitar. Somebody else says, oh, our Ellie has lessons, she loves it.

And then comes the sentence the whole thing hangs on: who does she go to?

That is the moment. That is the most valuable thing that can happen to a one person business, and it costs nothing, and it happens because you did a good job on somebody’s eleven year old for two years. There is no advertising budget on earth that buys what has just happened in that queue.

Here is the answer they get:

“Rob. Rob something. He’s brilliant with her, really patient. He’s somewhere over towards Heaton Moor I think. Hang on, I’ve got his number somewhere.”

And she has not got his number somewhere. It is in a WhatsApp thread from 2021. She scrolls for eight seconds, the queue moves, and the conversation moves on to something else.

What actually happens next

Three days later that other mum remembers she meant to sort out guitar lessons. She cannot remember my name. She has a rough shape of it: a bloke, Rob or Rod, somewhere near Heaton Moor, good with kids.

So she does what everybody does. She searches.

“guitar lessons stockport”

And this is the bit that took me an embarrassingly long time to understand. At the exact moment somebody has decided to give me their money, they get handed a page that has been built, deliberately and at great expense, to stop that happening.

What that search actually looks like

Try it for your own trade in your own town. It is the same everywhere.

  • Sponsored results, first. National tutoring platforms bidding on a search about me, in a town they have never been to, who will happily take a cut of a lesson I teach in my own house.
  • Then the map. Three teachers, ranked on review count and how close they are to the middle of town. Not on the fact that somebody who has actually met me told her to ring me.
  • Then the directories. Pages engineered to catch this exact search, showing me in a list of nineteen other guitar teachers, sorted by whoever paid.
  • Then, somewhere, maybe, me. Or the Facebook page I last posted on in 2022.

The recommendation is gone. Completely gone. She was told to ring one specific person and she is now comparing forty of us on price, and I am being weighed against somebody who started teaching in March and charges eight quid less because they have four students and I have thirty five.

The strongest marketing there is had been converted, in three days, into a generic search query. That is not Google being wicked. It is just that a search engine has no idea a recommendation ever happened, and neither does anybody else.

The things I tried, and why none of them worked

Business cards. I had five hundred printed. I have given out perhaps forty. The rest are in a drawer with a broken capo. The problem with a card is you have to be standing in front of somebody to give them one, and the person who needs it is the friend of the parent, three days later, in a different building.

A Facebook page. Genuinely useful for the people who already follow it, which is my current students’ parents, who do not need convincing. It is a broadcast channel with an audience of people who have already bought.

A website. I spent about four hundred pounds and three weekends on this. It has a home page, a lessons page, and an About page that still says “coming soon” four years later. It ranks nowhere, because I am one bloke and the directories have entire teams whose job is to be above me. Building it was a job I never finished, and finishing it would not have fixed anything, because the woman in the queue still cannot remember my name.

Paying a directory. I did this for five months. You pay per enquiry, the enquiries are shared with three other teachers, and you are effectively paying to be found by people who, quite often, were already told about you. Paying a fee to be introduced to somebody who already had my name is about the most annoying twenty pounds I have ever spent.

What I actually needed

It took me far too long to work out that I was solving the wrong problem. Every one of those things was an attempt to be found.

I did not need to be found. Somebody had already found me and told somebody else about me. What I needed was for the person doing the recommending to have something in their hand to give.

Not my phone number, typed from memory and one digit out. Something you can hold down and forward without thinking about it.

What I use now

I use usemy. It is one page, and one link, and it does the one job. Mine is at usemy.co/guitar-teacher/rob-callaghan, which you can read out loud, which matters more than I expected it to.

On it: a photo of me that my wife took in the back room. What I teach and who I teach. My prices, all three of them, in plain numbers. The areas I cover. A button that rings my phone and a button that opens WhatsApp. And underneath, a handful of lines from parents whose children I have taught for years, each with a first name and a town on it.

I filled it in between two lessons on a Tuesday and it was live before the next one started. There is nothing to maintain, which given the state of my actual website is the part I care about most.

The point is not the page. The point is that the parents I already teach now have something to send. It sits in their WhatsApp with a little preview card showing my face and my name. When somebody in the class group asks about guitar lessons, one of them pastes it in. The woman who asked never has to remember “Rob something”, and never has to search anything, and never sees a sponsored link for a tutoring platform in London.

What changed

I want to be careful here, because I have read enough of these to be suspicious of anybody claiming their life changed. It did not. I still teach the same hours in the same room.

What I can tell you is:

  • Nine enquiries in three months that I can put directly down to the link, because people say so when they ring.
  • Two of those came out of a Facebook group I am not a member of and have never seen.
  • Almost nobody opens with “how much do you charge?” any more, because they read it before they rang. That has saved me more time than anything else on this list.
  • One parent told me she had recommended me “loads of times” over four years. I had never heard about any of them. I have absolutely no idea how many students that cost me and I have decided to stop thinking about it.

If you teach guitar, or anything else

Most of this has nothing to do with guitar. It applies to anybody whose work arrives because somebody said their name: barbers, dog groomers, plasterers, piano teachers, photographers, anyone.

  • Give people a link, not a number. A number needs copying, checking and explaining. A link gets forwarded in one tap and arrives with your face on it.
  • Put your prices on it. Everybody in every trade is frightened of this and everybody who does it says the same thing: the people who ring are the people who were always going to book.
  • Ask the customers you already have. Not for a review. For permission to send them your link so they have it when somebody asks. It is a much smaller favour, and they say yes.
  • Put it where the work already is. Mine goes at the bottom of every invoice and on a card in the case of every student who takes a guitar home.

Word of mouth was never the weak link. I had plenty of it. The weak link was that a recommendation had nowhere to land, so it turned into a search, and a search is a room full of my competitors.

Give the people who already rate you something to hand over. That is the whole of it.

Questions people ask

How do most guitar teachers get students?
Almost entirely by word of mouth: current students' parents recommending them to other parents, at school gates, in class WhatsApp groups and in local Facebook groups. Paid advertising and directory listings are a distant second for a one person teaching business, and both put you alongside every other teacher in your town at the moment somebody has already decided to book.
Do I need a website to teach guitar?
Almost certainly not. A website is a project you have to finish and then keep finishing, and it will not outrank the tutoring directories for searches like 'guitar lessons near me'. What you need is one page a parent can forward when somebody asks them for your name, with your prices and a button that rings your phone.
Should I put my lesson prices online?
Yes. Cost is the second question anybody asks and hiding it only means answering it by text forty times a month. Publishing prices filters out the people who were never going to book and means the ones who ring have already accepted what you charge.
How do I ask a parent to recommend me without it being awkward?
Do not ask for a recommendation, and do not ask for a review. Send them your link and say that if anybody ever asks about lessons, that is the thing to send them. It is a far smaller favour than writing something, it costs them nothing, and it sits in their phone until it is needed.
What is the best way to get more guitar students locally?
Make it effortless for the students you already teach to pass you on. One shareable page with your prices, your areas, a photograph and a phone button will do more than advertising, because it turns a recommendation somebody was already making into an introduction instead of a half remembered name and a Google search.